Decision Matrix Example:   


 


A decision matrix is a tool whereby options (solutions) are measured against predetermined criteria.  It is simply a table where the columns are the criteria and the rows are the options.  For example, the decision matrix below shows that we have 4 potential options to resolve our problem and we want to measure them against 4 different criteria.


 


 


Criteria 1


Criteria 2


Criteria 3


Criteria 4


Total


 


Weight


Weight


Weight


Weight


 


Option 1


 


 


 


 


 


Option 2


 


 


 


 


 


Option 3


 


 


 


 


 


Option 4


 


 


 


 


 


 


 


AL480 Seminar in Health Care


Paper Evaluation and Grading Tool


 


Description of Facility:  (___ /10)                                         


Develop Problem Statement:  (___ /20)


 


Problem Classification:  (____/10)


            _____/5           Categorize the problem


_____/5 Can it be broken into smaller pieces?


Identify Critical Factors:  (_____/20)


_____/5 Who are the stakeholders?


_____/5 What risks are involved?


_____/5 What are the corporate culture / politics?


_____/5 What assumptions need to be made?


Data Collection:  (_____/15)


_____/10           What types of data would be collected?


_____/5 Who is going to collect the data?


Decision Making(_____/195)


_____/5 What type of decision-making is going to be used?


_____/20           What are the criteria for selecting the best solution?


_____/20           Description of the alternative solutions


_____/100         What are the implications for each alternative solution?


                                    Quality of Care (up to 5 pts for each of the 4 solutions)


                                    Organizational Policy (up to 5 pts for each of the 4 solutions)


                                    Management (up to 5 pts for each of the 4 solutions)


                                    Finance (up to 5 pts for each of the 4 solutions)


                                    Information Systems (up to 5 pts for each of the 4 solutions)


_____/20           Create a Decision Matrix


_____/30           Select best solution and explain why this solution was chosen


                                    Use the Decision Matrix to explain your selection


 


Implementation:  (_____/20)


_____/20         Develop an Implementation Plan


Evaluate and Provide Feedback:  (_____/20)


_____/10           How is monitoring going to take place?


_____/10           Can changes be made later?


 


Paper Requirements:  (_____/22 )                                       


_____/ 5          Cover Page complete


_____/5           Used appropriate headers within the paper       


_____/5           Use of sufficient references


_____/5           Submitted as a Word of rich text format


_____/2           Used correct font and line spacing


 


 


 




Credit:ivythesis.typepad.com


0 comments:

Post a Comment

 
Top